{
  "diversion": {
    "status": "Not identified",
    "conclusion": "The current Welsh map is not a verified complete historical network. The bounded source review did not establish exact effective dates and adjacent-road coverage sufficient for a displacement estimate. All-network and complementary speed-category comparisons are available; an adjacent-road causal test remains unsupported."
  },
  "wrexham": {
    "status": "Descriptive speed evidence; casualty effect unresolved",
    "source": "https://tfw.wales/vehicle-speed-monitoring-data-july-2023-to-september-2025",
    "observations": [
      {
        "period": "July2025",
        "limit": 20,
        "meanMph": 25.5,
        "p85Mph": 30.4,
        "vehicles": 526530
      },
      {
        "period": "September2025 \u00b7 two weeks",
        "limit": 30,
        "meanMph": 27.9,
        "p85Mph": 31.8,
        "vehicles": 533767
      }
    ],
    "conclusion": "At five sites, the published mean increased2.4mph between the July20mph and September30mph observations. September covers only two weeks. The source check found no later published site series, exact site-level reversal dates or matched injury follow-up sufficient for an injury-effect estimate. The short before/after comparison does not isolate the legal-limit effect from other changes. The five remaining Wrexham20mph sites averaged24.1 then24.0mph, but they were not assigned or matched controls. The published combined-volume footnote differs from its two source rows by180 observations; the two rows are retained here.",
    "missing": "Council programme completion expectations are not assumed to be operative dates for these monitored sites."
  },
  "edinburgh": {
    "heading": "Historical boundaries recovered; published arithmetic checked.",
    "conclusion": "The authors\u2019 repository contains seven historical zone polygons with phased dates and7,478 road features. That enables a concrete second-setting check. We reproduced aggregate calculations from the primary paper and author workbook; original collision-to-road assignment, matched controls, uncertainty intervals and causal attribution were not independently replicated. The historical research map is not a verified legal-order inventory, and its reuse licence remains unverified.",
    "phases": [
      {
        "zones": "1 \u00b7 two polygons",
        "date": "31 July2016"
      },
      {
        "zones": "2 and3",
        "date": "28 February2017"
      },
      {
        "zones": "4 and5",
        "date": "16 August2017"
      },
      {
        "zones": "6",
        "date": "5 March2018"
      }
    ],
    "benchmark": "The published Table2 rates reproduce differences in percentage changes of\u221222.31 percentage points for collisions and\u221219.71 points for casualties. Author zone counts and rounded follow-up durations give\u221222.13 points for collisions when combined with the paper\u2019s control rates. These are percentage-point contrasts, not relative risk reductions. A separate Table1 casualty contrast gives\u22129.15 points versus the reported\u221210 using printed inputs; that discrepancy remains explicit. Table2 omits zone2 while the workbook total includes it; the underlying control pairing is not reconciled.",
    "paper": "https://jech.bmj.com/content/78/7/437",
    "repository": "https://github.com/20mph-study/collision_analysis"
  }
}
