{
  "version": "20mph-phase1-v1",
  "frozenAt": "2026-11-03",
  "protocolSha256": "902d23d8d9746ce846bb7081645dee34e5efe9d5c01a59c19019a841c0a51f67",
  "inputHashes": {
    "stats19-guide-2021-2025": "51b08606ef3dad1ae5d4c8726241b022fc8e4bbdc910ef0e5cc2fb92b054fc12",
    "stats19-collision-2021-2025": "06a03c0e5504175e23ed98e3e0b4767ac61d396c073405a1bddab9339c18f948",
    "stats19-collision-2025": "e699c19bdb82e47e449b6f3381ac87631865f6a31cef118c9955ba80ca870e2b",
    "stats19-vehicle-2021-2025": "05453dca2651ad8a27b4ac0e6a0450a852c506e4d495111ffca398f3d311e26a",
    "stats19-vehicle-2025": "dbeadb9745a8821ab8132f0dde59c246159e23059ab5db2c9a4381d44141a430",
    "stats19-casualty-2021-2025": "870be5a934ae10baf5c52163d59eccba0ab2f40327ffa6b2bd354d2e7ee6b108",
    "stats19-casualty-2025": "b343039991f63f526bbcac0a5e6102e3a6e4c0b65d077e3ae37dbd53d1a7319a",
    "existing-geography-context": "fb5498178b3045194f74e771b5a0cb6a50e4c99b0d892c11a480243462596f0f"
  },
  "scope": "Data feasibility and reconciliation; no policy effect estimated",
  "checks": {
    "duplicateCollisions": 0,
    "duplicateVehicles": 0,
    "duplicateCasualties": 0,
    "orphanVehicles": 0,
    "orphanCasualties": 0,
    "casualtyVehicleOrphans": 0,
    "perCollisionCountMismatches": 0,
    "missingCoordinates": 53,
    "walesMissingCoordinates": 16,
    "walesHighwayCountryDisagreement": 18
  },
  "limitations": [
    "Record-level imports cover 2021–2025; 2015–2020 microdata extension remains required for the full protocol. Existing clock-change extracts cover event windows and cannot substitute for complete years.",
    "2016–2019 and 2022 annual area data support an initial comparison screen only. No area is certified untreated.",
    "Recorded 20/30 categories are a descriptive proxy; neither a fixed legal network nor compatible traffic exposure is established.",
    "The Welsh annual publication and imported speed strata do not fully reconcile. Resolve source vintage and classification before publishing a speed-specific trend.",
    "KSI analysis is withheld pending injury-reporting adjustments. Counts and fatalities are retained separately.",
    "TfW Table 4 distribution bins fail consistency checks; preserved as supplied and excluded from analytical use."
  ],
  "monitoringAuditSha256": "dde8b82496cb8ad9598b112364cba7ec3ee2e42fbb2ae95449797534d9f326e1",
  "annualGbCounts": [
    {
      "year": 2021,
      "collisions": 101087,
      "declaredVehicles": 186443,
      "declaredCasualties": 128209,
      "vehicles": 186443,
      "casualties": 128209
    },
    {
      "year": 2022,
      "collisions": 106004,
      "declaredVehicles": 193545,
      "declaredCasualties": 135480,
      "vehicles": 193545,
      "casualties": 135480
    },
    {
      "year": 2023,
      "collisions": 104258,
      "declaredVehicles": 189815,
      "declaredCasualties": 132977,
      "vehicles": 189815,
      "casualties": 132977
    },
    {
      "year": 2024,
      "collisions": 100927,
      "declaredVehicles": 183514,
      "declaredCasualties": 128272,
      "vehicles": 183514,
      "casualties": 128272
    },
    {
      "year": 2025,
      "collisions": 101525,
      "declaredVehicles": 183948,
      "declaredCasualties": 127883,
      "vehicles": 183948,
      "casualties": 127883
    }
  ],
  "revisionComparison2025": {
    "oldVintage": "2026-09-25",
    "newVintage": "2026-11-03",
    "added": 0,
    "removed": 0,
    "changedCollisionRecords": 0
  },
  "reconciliation": [
    {
      "year": 2025,
      "network": "all-roads",
      "measure": "collisions",
      "published": 3004,
      "observed": 3004,
      "difference": 0,
      "status": "matched"
    },
    {
      "year": 2025,
      "network": "all-roads",
      "measure": "casualties",
      "published": 4078,
      "observed": 4078,
      "difference": 0,
      "status": "matched"
    },
    {
      "year": 2025,
      "network": "all-roads",
      "measure": "killed",
      "published": 91,
      "observed": 91,
      "difference": 0,
      "status": "matched"
    },
    {
      "year": 2025,
      "network": "all-roads",
      "measure": "recordedSerious",
      "published": 1116,
      "observed": 1116,
      "difference": 0,
      "status": "matched"
    },
    {
      "year": 2025,
      "network": "all-roads",
      "measure": "fatalCollisions",
      "published": 83,
      "observed": 83,
      "difference": 0,
      "status": "matched"
    },
    {
      "year": 2025,
      "network": "recorded-20-or-30",
      "measure": "collisions",
      "published": 1469,
      "observed": 1488,
      "difference": 19,
      "status": "unresolved-vintage-or-classification"
    }
  ],
  "comparisonFeasibility": {
    "screenYears": [
      2016,
      2017,
      2018,
      2019,
      2022
    ],
    "englishAreas": 153,
    "completeUnflagged": 136,
    "approvedControls": 0,
    "welshAreas": 22,
    "method": "Pre-policy all-road count trajectories indexed to 2016; RMSE against pooled Wales. Screen only; policy contamination, road mix, mileage, demographics and 2015 remain unverified. No post-policy outcome used to choose candidates.",
    "firstCandidates": [
      {
        "area_id": "E08000021",
        "area": "Newcastle upon Tyne",
        "region": "North East",
        "complete_unflagged_preperiod": 1,
        "pretrend_index_rmse": 0.03193,
        "local_20mph_policy_checked": false,
        "selected_control": false
      },
      {
        "area_id": "E10000003",
        "area": "Cambridgeshire",
        "region": "East of England",
        "complete_unflagged_preperiod": 1,
        "pretrend_index_rmse": 0.03526,
        "local_20mph_policy_checked": false,
        "selected_control": false
      },
      {
        "area_id": "E10000024",
        "area": "Nottinghamshire",
        "region": "East Midlands",
        "complete_unflagged_preperiod": 1,
        "pretrend_index_rmse": 0.03689,
        "local_20mph_policy_checked": false,
        "selected_control": false
      },
      {
        "area_id": "E08000037",
        "area": "Gateshead",
        "region": "North East",
        "complete_unflagged_preperiod": 1,
        "pretrend_index_rmse": 0.03819,
        "local_20mph_policy_checked": false,
        "selected_control": false
      },
      {
        "area_id": "E08000026",
        "area": "Coventry",
        "region": "West Midlands",
        "complete_unflagged_preperiod": 1,
        "pretrend_index_rmse": 0.04077,
        "local_20mph_policy_checked": false,
        "selected_control": false
      },
      {
        "area_id": "E06000026",
        "area": "Plymouth",
        "region": "South West",
        "complete_unflagged_preperiod": 1,
        "pretrend_index_rmse": 0.04188,
        "local_20mph_policy_checked": false,
        "selected_control": false
      },
      {
        "area_id": "E06000011",
        "area": "East Riding of Yorkshire",
        "region": "Yorkshire and The Humber",
        "complete_unflagged_preperiod": 1,
        "pretrend_index_rmse": 0.04242,
        "local_20mph_policy_checked": false,
        "selected_control": false
      },
      {
        "area_id": "E10000034",
        "area": "Worcestershire",
        "region": "West Midlands",
        "complete_unflagged_preperiod": 1,
        "pretrend_index_rmse": 0.04643,
        "local_20mph_policy_checked": false,
        "selected_control": false
      }
    ]
  },
  "districtAuditGrid": {
    "rows": 20280,
    "districts": 338,
    "zeroCollisionCells": 902,
    "warning": "Observed district universe; changing boundaries and entry/exit may create structural zeros. Not approved as a causal panel; not a road universe."
  },
  "power": {
    "method": "Illustrative two-sided 5% test, 80% power, log ratio-of-ratios Poisson approximation: (1.96+0.842)*sqrt(D*sum(1/N)). Report 100*(1-exp(-threshold)). Counts projected from 2022 for 80 pre and 27 post months, control volume 1x/3x. No estimated serial correlation or design validation.",
    "scenarios": [
      {
        "network": "all-roads",
        "baseline2022AnnualCollisions": 3315,
        "preMonthsAssumed": 80,
        "postMonthsAssumed": 27,
        "controlCountMultiple": 1,
        "varianceInflation": 1,
        "approxDetectableReductionPct": 5.17
      },
      {
        "network": "all-roads",
        "baseline2022AnnualCollisions": 3315,
        "preMonthsAssumed": 80,
        "postMonthsAssumed": 27,
        "controlCountMultiple": 1,
        "varianceInflation": 2,
        "approxDetectableReductionPct": 7.23
      },
      {
        "network": "all-roads",
        "baseline2022AnnualCollisions": 3315,
        "preMonthsAssumed": 80,
        "postMonthsAssumed": 27,
        "controlCountMultiple": 1,
        "varianceInflation": 4,
        "approxDetectableReductionPct": 10.07
      },
      {
        "network": "all-roads",
        "baseline2022AnnualCollisions": 3315,
        "preMonthsAssumed": 80,
        "postMonthsAssumed": 27,
        "controlCountMultiple": 3,
        "varianceInflation": 1,
        "approxDetectableReductionPct": 4.24
      },
      {
        "network": "all-roads",
        "baseline2022AnnualCollisions": 3315,
        "preMonthsAssumed": 80,
        "postMonthsAssumed": 27,
        "controlCountMultiple": 3,
        "varianceInflation": 2,
        "approxDetectableReductionPct": 5.94
      },
      {
        "network": "all-roads",
        "baseline2022AnnualCollisions": 3315,
        "preMonthsAssumed": 80,
        "postMonthsAssumed": 27,
        "controlCountMultiple": 3,
        "varianceInflation": 4,
        "approxDetectableReductionPct": 8.3
      },
      {
        "network": "recorded-20-or-30",
        "baseline2022AnnualCollisions": 1885,
        "preMonthsAssumed": 80,
        "postMonthsAssumed": 27,
        "controlCountMultiple": 1,
        "varianceInflation": 1,
        "approxDetectableReductionPct": 6.79
      },
      {
        "network": "recorded-20-or-30",
        "baseline2022AnnualCollisions": 1885,
        "preMonthsAssumed": 80,
        "postMonthsAssumed": 27,
        "controlCountMultiple": 1,
        "varianceInflation": 2,
        "approxDetectableReductionPct": 9.47
      },
      {
        "network": "recorded-20-or-30",
        "baseline2022AnnualCollisions": 1885,
        "preMonthsAssumed": 80,
        "postMonthsAssumed": 27,
        "controlCountMultiple": 1,
        "varianceInflation": 4,
        "approxDetectableReductionPct": 13.13
      },
      {
        "network": "recorded-20-or-30",
        "baseline2022AnnualCollisions": 1885,
        "preMonthsAssumed": 80,
        "postMonthsAssumed": 27,
        "controlCountMultiple": 3,
        "varianceInflation": 1,
        "approxDetectableReductionPct": 5.58
      },
      {
        "network": "recorded-20-or-30",
        "baseline2022AnnualCollisions": 1885,
        "preMonthsAssumed": 80,
        "postMonthsAssumed": 27,
        "controlCountMultiple": 3,
        "varianceInflation": 2,
        "approxDetectableReductionPct": 7.8
      },
      {
        "network": "recorded-20-or-30",
        "baseline2022AnnualCollisions": 1885,
        "preMonthsAssumed": 80,
        "postMonthsAssumed": 27,
        "controlCountMultiple": 3,
        "varianceInflation": 4,
        "approxDetectableReductionPct": 10.85
      }
    ],
    "conclusion": "Counts may support an area descriptive pilot. These optimistic sensitivities cannot establish causal power for one treated nation; estimate dependence and perform placebo/block simulations after the control panel is verified. No subgroup power claimed."
  },
  "roadCoverage": {
    "registeredSections": 0,
    "verifiedSections": 0,
    "networkLengthKm": null,
    "coveragePct": null,
    "collisionMatchRate": null,
    "status": "Road causal panel blocked: no section with both verified legal date and versioned geometry. Current map and national start date do not establish full historical coverage."
  },
  "decision": {
    "phase1": "Feasibility audit complete, with explicit blockers",
    "phase2": "Conditional go: all-road descriptive pilot after historical import and documented geography checks. Show the publication reconciliation alongside any category-based view.",
    "roadCausalStudy": "Hold: dated road geometry, compatible exposure and uncontaminated comparisons not verified",
    "causalEffect": null
  }
}
